The symbol indicates that this is a Revenue Share question. You can earn money for charity by answering it now! This month we are donating Revenue Share Answer Revenues to the American Red Cross.
  1. Become an Experts123 Paid Contributor.
  2. Answer this question accurately and thoroughly.
  3. Earn revenue while your answer is ranked #1!
×
Q:

Don't surgeons train on animals before operating on humans?

2
Like
Answer
Comment
Flag
Thanks for your feedback!
A:

4 Answers

rank
1
2
Like
Comment
Flag
Many surgeons do trials on pigs and other lab animals. Many other surgeons - both present day and past - have admitted that work on animals confuses procedures. Even with limited medical knowledge, common sense suggests that orthopedic surgeries will be much different in a dog, for example, than in a human. Ophthalmologists perfected radial keratotomy on rabbits, then tried them out on humans. Only after completely blinding several humans, did they finally correct the procedure. The field of neurosurgery offers another example. Extracranial-intracranial (EC-IC) bypass procedures for inoperable carotid artery disease were tested and perfected on dogs and rabbits. Neurosurgeons performed thousands of EC-ICs before it was discovered the operation did more harm than good. More patients died or suffered strokes because of the operation than were saved as a result of it. Transplantation surgeries are much the same story. Hundreds and hundreds of cats, dogs, pigs and primates have been ...  more
whitecoatwelfare.org
2 more sources
Hide

Related Videos

rank
2
2
Like
Comment
Flag
http://www.curedisease.com/index.html Many surgeons do trials on pigs and other lab animals. Many other surgeons - both present day and past - have admitted that work on animals confuses procedures. Even with limited medical knowledge, common sense suggests that orthopedic surgeries will be much different in a dog, for example, than in a human. Ophthalmologists perfected radial keratotomy on rabbits, then tried them out on humans. Only after completely blinding several humans, did they finally correct the procedure. The field of neurosurgery offers another example. Extracranial-intracranial (EC-IC) bypass procedures for inoperable carotid artery disease were tested and perfected on dogs and rabbits. Neurosurgeons performed thousands of EC-ICs before it was discovered the operation did more harm than good. More patients died or suffered strokes because of the operation than were saved as a result of it. Transplantation surgeries are much the same story. Hundreds and hundreds of cats, ...  more
all-creatures.org
rank
3
2
Like
Comment
Flag
Many surgeons have done trial procedures on lab animals, but many others have admitted that working on animals confuses the issue. Common sense suggests that orthopaedic surgery on a dog, for example, will differ greatly from that on a human. Applying animal data to the human body is always unscientific. Here are some examples: • Once ophthalmologists practiced radial keratotomy (corrective eye surgery) on rabbits, they later tried it out on humans. After blinding many individuals, doctors modified the procedure for the human eye. Had they originated their research on the human eye through in vitro or autopsy research, these tragedies would have been prevented. • Extracranial-intracranial (EC-IC) bypass procedures for inoperable carotid artery disease were tested and perfected on dogs and rabbits. Once approved for humans, neurosurgeons performed thousands of EC-ICs before they discovered the operation caused death and strokes more often than it resulted in recovery.[27] • Thousands ...  more
curedisease.net
rank
4
1
Like
Comment
Flag
Many surgeons have done trial procedures on lab animals, but many others have admitted that working on animals confuses the issue. Common sense suggests that orthopaedic surgery on a dog, for example, will differ greatly from that on a human. Applying animal data to the human body is always unscientific. Here are some examples: Once ophthalmologists practiced radial keratotomy (corrective eye surgery) on rabbits, they later tried it out on humans. After blinding many individuals, doctors modified the procedure for the human eye. Had they originated their research on the human eye through in vitro or autopsy research, these tragedies would have been prevented. Extracranial-intracranial (EC-IC) bypass procedures for inoperable carotid artery disease were tested and perfected on dogs and rabbits. Once approved for humans, neurosurgeons performed thousands of EC-ICs before they discovered the operation caused death and strokes more often than it resulted in recovery.[27] Thousands of ...  more

Add your answer...

Top Related Experts

1.
Melissa Brown
Animals expert · Articles · 4 Likes
2.
Kathy Dendy
Animals expert · Articles · 1 Like
3.
Ron Gragg
Christianity expert · Articles · 0 Likes
4.
5.
Mandi Raymond
Animals expert · Articles · 0 Likes

Top Answerers

1.
vanity fair
11 Answers in the past week
2.
Robert Turner
4 Answers in the past week
3.
Ruby Rupert
3 Answers in the past week

Top Askers

1.
Deitty smith
3 Questions in the past week
2.
Charles McAtee
2 Questions in the past week
3.
Frank Bell
2 Questions in the past week

Top Supporters

1.
Tom Wagner
9 Likes given in the past week
2.
Rachel Kellen Gill
3 Likes given in the past week
3.
Nancy Hayden
2 Likes given in the past week
...