What is the difference between false light invasion of privacy and defamation?
The distinction between the two is a subtle one. The false light cause of action focuses upon indignity and defamation focuses upon reputation. >>top Question: How does the First Amendment to the Constitution affect defamation? Answer: The free speech guarantees under the Constitution protect certain speech and commentary. The degree of protection generally depends on whether the person commented about is a private or public figure and whether the statement is regarding a private or public matter. According to the New York Times rule (from the case New York Times v. Sullivan), when the plaintiff is a public figure and the matter is one of public concern, the plaintiff must prove “malice” or “reckless disregard” on the part of the defendant. If both parties are private individuals, there is less protection for the speech because the plaintiff only needs to prove negligence.