I have a Sound Blaster and when I record track 1, then track 2, the second track records tracks 1 and 2. What gives?
One possible quick fix is to go into your SB Mixer and change the Recording from “What You Hear” to “Line In” or “Mic” depending on what input you are using. If that doesn’t fix it it’s a signal routing issue, you need to mentally follow your signals and see where they meet before entering the sound card.