Is the search for a cardiac contractility index a futile cycle?
Our previous studies indicate that left ventricular end-systolic pressure-volume relations (ESPVRs) or elastance (Ees) are not reduced in studies where expected reductions of contractility should be found (i.e., heart failure, stunning, and endotoxemia). The present study was done to assess whether this phenomenon is due to a particular load sensitivity of elastance, rendering this index inappropriate as a measurement of contractility in pathologic states in vivo. METHODS AND RESULTS: Analysis of previously generated data revealed an increased ESPVR in stunned hearts, in pigs made endotoxemic, and in hearts rapidly paced. After inducing acute heart failure by microembolization, the ESPVR was increased when assessed using linear relations but reduced when assessing ESPVR by a curvilinear algorithm. To further evaluate the effect of different load alterations on ESPVR, this relation was generated by (i) inferior vena caval occlusions (VCOs); (ii) gradually occluding the descending aorta
